Explaining Complex Astronomical Observation Experiments to Middle School Students Using Simple Physics Methods

National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences; Huizhou No.1 Middle School

Like other branches of physics, astronomy involves both experiment and theory. Theoretical astronomy employs the same tools and methods as other theoretical physics disciplines. However, experimental astronomy differs from other experimental sciences because we cannot control the objects of our experiments—we can only observe various astronomical phenomena in the universe. In practice, though, there is almost no distinction between the design and execution of experiments in physics and the design and execution of astronomical observations, and certainly no fundamental difference in the scientific methodology of inquiry. This paper adopts the simplest physics methods to explain complex astronomical observation experiments to middle school students.

Keywords: astronomy; observation experiments; optics; data imaging

Astronomy is a branch of physics that, broadly speaking, investigates large-scale phenomena—the Sun, planets, stars, galaxies, and the entire universe. Moreover, much of astronomy involves phenomena at the microscopic particle level. Today we generally define astronomy as the physics of distant objects and phenomena. Since the physical phenomena covered by astronomy are diverse, witnessing these phenomena firsthand constitutes an important method for obtaining evidence in astronomical research.

2 Advantages of Telescope Observation Over Human Eye Observation

We conduct astronomical observations and experiments by detecting and measuring electromagnetic radiation from distant celestial bodies. To record and characterize electromagnetic radiation, at minimum we need a camera to focus the approximately planar electromagnetic waves from a distant light source, and a detector located at the camera's focal plane to record the signal. An astronomical telescope is simply another name for a camera specifically designed to observe distant objects. The most basic camera-detector combination is the human eye, which consists of a lens (the camera) that focuses images onto the retina (the detector). Photosensitive cells on the retina then convert the light intensity of the image into neural signals transmitted to the brain.

Before Galileo introduced the telescope to astronomical observation experiments, astronomy relied solely on the human eye. However, the eye has numerous drawbacks as an astronomical tool. The dark-adapted pupil has an aperture smaller than 1 centimeter, resulting in limited light-gathering area and angular resolution. A camera's light-gathering capability depends on its aperture area (for example, the objective lens aperture or the primary mirror aperture of a reflecting telescope). The larger the aperture, the more photons can be detected per unit time, enabling observation of fainter light sources. Currently, the primary mirror diameter of the largest operational visible-light telescope on Earth is

3 Physics Explanation of Telescope Angular Resolution

A telescope's angular resolution refers to the minimum angular separation between two light sources in the sky that can be recognized as distinct sources by the camera. According to wave optics principles, when a plane wave of wavelength λ passes through a circular aperture of diameter D and focuses on a detector, it produces a concentric ring diffraction pattern. The center of these rings coincides with the position expected from geometric optics, and the angular radius of the central spot (in radians) is θ=1.22. For example, consider an image of a star field taken by a camera equipped with a band-pass filter that only allows light within a specific wavelength range to pass through. This image will consist of a set of such diffraction patterns, with each star's position corresponding to one pattern. To actually observe these diffraction patterns, one must ensure the image is not blurred, either due to imperfections in the optical system construction or due to other factors such as Earth's atmosphere. When the angular separation between the central points of the diffraction patterns of two adjacent sources in the sky is less than λ/D, they will overlap and become difficult to distinguish.

Similarly, a light source with angular dimensions smaller than this diffraction limit will produce an unresolved image that is indistinguishable from that produced by a point source with zero angular extent. Therefore, in principle, a 10-meter telescope operating at the same visible wavelengths as the eye could have an angular resolution 1000 times better than the eye. In practice, due to the constantly changing and blurring effects of the atmosphere, ground-based optical telescopes rarely achieve diffraction-limited performance. The optical wavelength range of electromagnetic radiation is roughly defined as 0.32–1 micrometer. However, in radio and infrared astronomy, diffraction-limited angular resolution observations are routine, and significant progress has been made in this area in the optical range in recent years. Angular resolution is crucial not only for discerning details of astronomical sources (for example, observing Jupiter's moons and surface features, the components of star-forming regions, or fine details in galaxies), but also for detecting faint unresolved sources against the background of Earth's atmospheric emission.

4 Principles of Astronomical Data Image Formation

The night sky shines due to scattered light from stars, the Moon, and artificial light sources, as well as fluorescence from atoms and molecules in the atmosphere. The higher a telescope's angular resolution, the smaller the solid angle over which a star's light is spread, and thus the higher the contrast between that star's image and statistical fluctuations in the sky background.

In astronomical observations, detectors can collect weak signals over arbitrarily long exposures, thereby detecting extremely faint light sources. A disadvantage of the human eye is that it is only sensitive to a narrow visual range of electromagnetic radiation wavelengths (approximately 0.4–0.7 micrometers, which falls within the optical range defined above), whereas astronomical information exists across all regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, from radio through infrared, visible, ultraviolet, X-ray, and gamma-ray bands. Finally, detectors other than the eye can preserve an objective record of the observation that can then be examined, analyzed, and disseminated.

Astronomical data are always saved in digital format for subsequent computer processing. Today, all telescopes used for professional astronomy are equipped with detectors for recording data. The detectors used in optical, near-ultraviolet, and X-ray astronomy are almost exclusively charge-coupled devices (CCDs), the same type of detector used in digital cameras. A CCD is a silicon wafer divided into countless pixels by an insulating buffer layer etched onto the wafer and selected voltage differences applied across its area. Photons arriving at the CCD release photoelectrons through the photoelectric effect. The photoelectrons accumulated in each pixel during an exposure are then read out and amplified, producing an electric current proportional to the number of photons reaching the pixel. This enables the creation of a digital image of the observed sky region. The astronomical observation technique of generating images by focusing a portion of the sky onto a detector is called imaging. Every parameter characterizing an electromagnetic wave can carry useful astronomical information, and different techniques have been designed to measure these parameters.

Furthermore, we can measure the intensity of the signal produced by a light source. For example, in photon-counting devices, this is done by counting the total number of photons collected from the source over an integration time. Photon flux is related to intensity, which is the time-averaged square of the electric field amplitude ( ). Measuring a source's photon flux is called photometry. In time-resolved photometry, we can make repeated measurements of brightness variations over time, thereby measuring the time dependence of .

5 Spectroscopy in Astronomical Observation Experiments

The wavelength λ (or frequency ν) of light can be determined in several ways. A band-pass filter placed before the detector allows only electromagnetic radiation within a specific wavelength range to reach the detector while blocking all other wavelengths. Alternatively, light can be reflected or transmitted through a dispersive element such as a prism or diffraction grating before reaching the detector. Light of different wavelengths will be deflected at different angles, thereby landing at different positions on the detector. Consequently, a single light source will be spread out into a spectrum, with the signal at each position in the spectrum proportional to the intensity at different wavelengths. This technique is called spectroscopy.

The phase shift φ of a light wave arriving at the detector can reveal its precise direction of arrival, as well as effects such as scattering that the wave experienced along its path from the source to the detector. Phase can be measured by combining electromagnetic waves received from the same source to create an interference pattern, a method known as interferometry. In interferometry, the baseline distance B between the most widely separated telescopes replaces the aperture in determining angular resolution as λ/B. In radio astronomy, signals from radio telescopes spread across the globe and even in space are routinely combined, providing baselines on the order of 10⁴ kilometers and very high angular resolution.

The amount of polarization, the type of polarization (linear, circular), and the direction of the polarization vector in the sky can be determined. In optical astronomy, this is achieved by placing a polarizing filter in the beam, allowing only specific polarization components to reach the detector. Measuring the polarization characteristics of a light source is called polarimetry. While it has always been desirable to characterize all parameters of the electromagnetic waves emitted by a source, this is rarely feasible in practice. However, multiple characteristics can often be measured simultaneously, and these techniques are therefore given appropriate names, such as spectropolarimetry, where both the intensity and polarization of the light emitted by a source are measured as functions of wavelength.

References

1. Nie Qingxiang, et al., Fundamentals of Astronomy, Beijing: China Personnel Publishing House, 1996.
2. He Xiangtao, Observational Cosmology, Beijing: Science Press, 2002.
3. Cui Zhenhua, et al., Astronomical Museum, Zhengzhou: Henan Education Press, 1995.
4. Ye Shuhua, Concise Dictionary of Astronomy, Shanghai: Shanghai Dictionary Publishing House, 1986.
5. Xuan Huancan, History of Astronomy, Beijing: Higher Education Press, 1992.